A panuozzo is sort of like a giant sandwich made with pizza dough, and San Matteo is one of the few places in NYC where you can get one. This place also does about 25 different kinds of pizza (and we tend prefer those), and they also have pasta, calzones, and small plates - which makes this a pretty solid neighborhood Italian option. The space is large, with brick walls and plenty of windows, and it’s perfect for a casual dinner with some friends or a few children that you’re responsible for feeding. Start with some antipasti, move on to the pizza, and order a bottle of wine if you don’t have anywhere to be in the morning.
Where we've featured it
Casual Italian: the reliable, neighborhood spots you want to be at every Sunday night. Here are our favorites.
More spots in Upper East SideSee more
The Daisy is an Upper East Side restaurant and cocktail bar that serves American-ish food that you’ve likely already tried before and know you like.
Doc Watson’s is an Upper East Side bar with sidewalk seating and a small beer garden in the back.
More Italian spotsSee more
Gran Tivoli is an Italian spot in Nolita that’s best for drinks and a light bite rather than a full dinner.
A little Italian cafe and sandwich shop on the Upper East Side near Central Park. We love the sandwiches, but hate how much they cost.
Suggested by our writers
The East Pole
The East Pole is a restaurant where you should meet a friend for a martini in the east 60s.
The Penrose is one of several Upper East Side restaurants that are making this neighborhood sort of cool again. Sort of.
Sushi Seki Upper East Side
Open late and always excellent, Sushi Seki Upper East Side is our favorite sushi restaurant in NYC. Sit at the counter and order piece by piece.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more