Unless you live in Brooklyn Heights, you’ve likely never heard of Noodle Pudding. This is the definition of a hidden gem: no website, no sign, cash-only, and a name so dumb you’d have to know this place was good in order to walk in. What you get is above-average Italian at affordable prices in an atmosphere that feels more down-to-earth than any new place with fancy flatware and a font supervisor. Bring cash, bring your parents, bring a date, or just bring yourself and eat heaps of gnocchi.
Where we've featured it
Casual Italian: the reliable, neighborhood spots you want to be at every Sunday night. Here are our favorites.
More spots in BrooklynSee more
Baba Cool Cafe
Baba Cool is an all-day cafe in Fort Greene that’s an ideal lunch option for vegetarians.
More Italian spotsSee more
D’Antan is an Italian spot in Crown Heights with more than 100 natural wines available by the glass.
Quality Italian is a neo-classic Italian restaurant in Midtown melded with a steakhouse. We like it for the variety on the menu and the massive space.
Bonafini is a neighborhood Italian restaurant in Prospect Lefferts Gardens that’s great for a casual date or dinner with your kids.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more