If you’re looking for a slice on the Upper West Side, you have some options. Mama’s Too is the best one - but what if you’re about 25 blocks south of there? Go to Made In New York. Sure, it has a redundant name, but the square pepperoni slice with its crispy cups and crunchy crust is excellent. The square white slice is also very good, as is the upside down one covered in an especially sweet tomato sauce. There are also a bunch of tables if you’d like to eat your slice immediately after purchasing it - but we usually just take ours to go.
More spots in Upper West SideSee more
George Keeley is a bar on the Upper West Side where you can watch sports and drink a hard-to-find draft beer.
The Smith Lincoln Center
That's right, another Infatuation review for yet another location of The Smith. Why? Because The Smith is always there when you need it to be. Sometimes for the food. Sometimes for the bathroom. Either way, it's there, and it's good.
More Pizza spotsSee more
Totonno Pizzeria Napolitana
Legendary thin crust pizza that you should make the trip to Coney Island for.
Lucali is a walk-in-only spot in Carroll Gardens that serves the best pizza in New York City.
Sofia Pizza Shoppe
Sofia Pizza Shoppe is a tiny slice spot that serves some of the best pizza in Midtown.
Suggested by our writers
Emmy Squared in Williamsburg is the adult version of your childhood pizza party dreams.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more