There are two ways you can do Mike’s. You can wait in line, place an order, sit down, and then wait for another 30 to 40 minutes for your buckets of fried seafood to arrive. Or, you can place an order over the phone, pick everything up with no wait, and take it all home to dig into in the privacy of your beach house. Unless you’re someone who enjoys chaos, the latter is the way to go. You’ll get the same tins filled with battered fish and crab claws doused in Old Bay, but without being stepped on by people still in their bathing suits and squeaky rubber flip flops.
Where we've featured it
More spots in Sea Isle CitySee more
More Seafood spotsSee more
Stefano’s is a fine-dining, BYOB spot on Long Beach Island where you can get great Italian or seafood, or both.
Devon Seafood Grill
Devon Seafood in Rittenhouse is exactly where you should go for a big event, or when you have a corporate card, to eat a lot of shellfish.
Suggested by our writers
La Finestra is an Italian BYOB in Sea Isle City where you should bring a date if you’re trying to impress them.
Water Star Grille
Water Star Grille is an indoor-outdoor restaurant on the bay in Stone Harbor that looks like it might as well be in the Hamptons.
Circle Pizza is pretty much the only place you want to get pizza from if you’re in Avalon or Stone Harbor.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more