This Caribbean spot on 5th Avenue is a real triple threat: the Jamaican cocktails are memorable, their jerk lamb meatballs and stuffed snapper are worth traveling for, and they even have a few booths for small groups on their sidewalk patio. The catch is, a lot of people know these three things already, which is why their first come first served patio is usually packed on weekends. Show up early for a Sunday night table or stop by for oxtails on a weeknight.
Where we've featured it
Search by Perfect For
More spots in BrooklynSee more
While the burger and the brunch menu are great, the rest of the menu at Cafe Colette falls short.
Jupiter Disco is a little space-themed bar in Bushwick that isn’t as tacky as it sounds.
Renegades of Sunset
If you’re looking for some fun vegan food in Industry City, go to Renegades of Sunset.
More Caribbean spotsSee more
Jasmine’s Caribbean Cuisine
Jasmine’s is a Caribbean restaurant in Midtown with dishes like ackee and saltfish, curry chicken, and rasta pasta.
Allan’s Bakery is a third-generation cultural institution and Caribbean bakery in Flatbush with incredible currants rolls, hard dough bread, and more.
Suggested by our writers
Peppa’s Jerk Chicken
Peppa’s in Prospect Lefferts Gardens is a counter-service Caribbean spot about a block from the park.
Jerk Pan is a great Jamaican food truck that’s parked right next to the J.P. Morgan building on 48th and Park Avenue in Midtown East.
Errol’s Caribbean Bakery
Errol’s Caribbean bakery makes the best coconut rolls in the neighborhood, and some very good jerk chicken.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more