NYCGuide

The Best Pizza In Brooklyn

Oxtail pies in Bed-Stuy, classic square slices in Gravesend, and more pizza you need to try in the city's most populous borough.
The Best Pizza In Brooklyn image

photo credit: Teddy Wolff

If you want the best pizza in New York City, head to Brooklyn. There's a mind-boggling amount of good options in this borough, from trendy spots where you'll wait hours for a transcendent pie, to slice shops where you can walk in and have an out-of-body eating experience on a whim.

THE SPOTS

photo credit: Teddy Wolff

Pizza

Williamsburg

$$$$Perfect For:Casual Weeknight DinnerCheap EatsImpressing Out of TownersKidsLunchQuick Eats
Earn 3x points with your sapphire card

L'Industrie doesn't just make some of the best pizza in Brooklyn. They make some of the best pizza in New York, full stop. The crust manages to be thin, crisp, chewy, and airy all at once, and there's always the perfect amount of char to give it some bite. We especially love the burrata pie, which might just be the best use of burrata we've come across. L'industrie is also extremely consistent, which is part of what makes standing in line on a busy night for a slice so worth it. 

Yes, you still have to kind of plan your entire day around going to Lucali, but that’s part of what makes it special. Many New Yorkers agree that this is some of the best pizza in all five boroughs, so find an excuse to take off from work early and line up at 4pm to secure your spot in line. While you’re here, get a calzone along with your pizza. Since there are only two things on the menu, there’s no reason not to go all out. 

For many Brooklynites, there’s the L&B square slice, and then there’s everything else. The defining feature of this pizza is the fact that the cheese is layered underneath the sauce, creating an almost mochi-like chew where the thick crust and cheese meet. The sauce is, dare we say, to die for. Get a whole pie, even if you come here alone. It reheats beautifully. 

Even after the passing of Dom DeMarco, Di Fara still holds up as some of the absolute best pizza in Brooklyn. The sauce is deeply flavorful with a hit of acid, the crust is perfectly crisp and a bit charred, and fresh olive oil and basil tie the whole thing together. Go here if you want to understand the origin stories of other popular spots like Lucali and L’Industrie. Di Fara walked so they could follow in his footsteps. The wait times aren't as brutal as they used to be, especially if you’re just getting a slice. We prefer the round slice to the square, but both are excellent examples of the form. 

You could break all the entries on this list into two categories: places that would put ramps on pizza, and places that would not. Ops belongs in the first bucket, but their various seasonal toppings—which range from sweet potatoes to aji dulce peppers—are only part of the reason why you come here. Tangy, fluffy, and perfectly charred, Ops’ sourdough crust is one of the better inventions of the 2010s. Most of the pies here are a cross between New York and Neapolitan-style, but there’s an exceptional, crunchy square option as well. This Bushwick spot also has a list of natural wines and a candlelit dining room, so it’s perfect for a casual date.

Even the greatest slice places are generally not establishments where you want to stay and hang for a while. That’s what makes Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop different. It’s an order-at-the-counter spot, with a beer and wine bar at the back of the space where you’ll find people posted up eating pizza, watching sports, and playing on a vintage video game console. Unlike the original Paulie Gee’s, this is not Neapolitan-style pizza—it’s classic New York slices and pies (including plenty of vegan options), plus the Sicilian style, sesame-crusted Freddy Prince, which is the best thing here.

If the Brooklyn pop-up pizza scene feels a little bleak after Chrissy’s Pizza moved from Bushwick to the East Village, that’s only because you’re not eating enough Wizard Hat Pizza. The naturally leavened pies are crispy, chewy, and showered in basil, and you should try the spicy pepperoni pizza on your first visit. Then go back for the other five pies. This pop-up is now operating regularly out of a space in Prospect Lefferts Gardens, and we’d recommend ordering ahead for same-day pick-up. Oh, and we should probably mention—Wizard Hat thinks it’s okay if you dip your pizza in ranch.

This Bay Ridge slice shop feels like it’s stuck in the 1980s, and we love that. We also love Elegante’s square slice, which feels a little like an L&B square, but with the sauce and cheese order reversed. The cheese is satisfyingly stretchy, and the crust is thick and chewy, but still light enough that you could easily eat more than one slice. 

photo credit: Alex Staniloff

Brooklyn is full of excellent pepperoni pies and pillowy square slices, but if your Friday pizza night is in need of a refresh, why not try a funkily shaped pork belly and bottarga-topped pizza under the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway? At Farina, a Southern Italian restaurant on the border of Carroll Gardens and Red Hook, the “irregolare” pizzas are slightly heftier than a classic Neapolitan, smaller than regular pies, and topped with things like apricot jam, and mashed potatoes. After your quarterly Big Red Hook Excursion, head here for perfectly charred pies made with seven-grain flour, along with some house wine.

Everything on the menu at Omar’s Fine Indian Cuisine is worth trying, but we’re here to talk about the Indian pizza. There are seven different Indian-inspired pizza options here, and chicken tikka pie, with its overwhelming amount of cream and cheese, is just as gratifying as it sounds. We also love the tawa vegetable version, which adds a much-needed masala kick to your usual vegetarian pizza. 

At the incredibly popular Cuts & Slices in Bed-Stuy, you’ll see chicken & waffle, black truffle alfredo shrimp, and lasagna pizzas. This place sets itself apart from other slice shops by offering a bunch of uncommon toppings, and while varieties like curry shrimp and jerk salmon are interesting, the real reasons to come here are the oxtail pies. There are three different kinds, and the sweet chili one comes loaded with crispy, tender shredded oxtail. The chewy crust will remind you of a buttermilk biscuit (in taste, not texture), and it’s a good understated vehicle for all the aggressively-flavored toppings.

Several years ago, there was a Detroit-style pizza boom. Suddenly, you could find it on every corner, and the children were revising their birthday wishlists to include fluffy, rectangular pies. Now that the dust has settled, we’re ready to declare a winner: Ace’s. We’re fans of this Williamsburg spot, and not just because it looks like a ‘70s pizza parlor, complete with arcade games and VHS tapes. Their pies are thick, but airy, with zesty tomato sauce and crunchy browned cheese lining the edges. Each bite is deeply satisfying in a way that’ll haunt you for days.

Leo stands out as one of the few spots in Brooklyn that has really good pizza without an outrageous wait. (Yes, we’re talking about you, Lucali.) In fact, you could gather a group last minute, show up here, and it’ll likely not be a problem. Although the margherita is an automatic order at a lot of places, we prefer the pies with toppings here, like the garlicky clam version. The crust is somewhere between New York style and Neapolitan, and you’ll taste a noticeable tang because it’s made with sourdough.

Lucia is a slice shop with deep roots in Brooklyn. The owner comes from the same dynasty behind Smiling Pizza and Papa Leone, and excellent sauce in a number of styles flows freely through their veins. If you’re only getting one slice here, make it the Caramelle Picante, a mix of hot cherry peppers, pepperoni, and Mike’s Hot Honey. But there’s also the Papa Leone—a very good vodka slice that uses a '70s-era sauce recipe from the family’s old Manhattan beach spot—and the clam pie, which you can only get on Fridays. Settle down at a table with your pizza-loving friends, and order as much as you can eat. It’s worth the schlep from wherever you live. 

There are two reasons to eat at Espresso Pizzeria. The first is because you want to have the platonic ideal of a Brooklyn street slice, with a good balance of crackly crust, deeply flavorful sauce, and very stretchy cheese. The second reason to come here is because you know their garlic knots are special. Unlike most other slice shops, which use pizza dough scraps for their knots, these are made from dough that had no other purpose. They’re light, incredibly thick and fluffy, and drenched in garlic butter with a generous dusting of parmesan and parsley. 

photo credit: Sonal Shah

$$$$Perfect For:Quick Eats

There are a lot of good pizza spots in Brooklyn, but there aren’t a lot of pizza spots where you can eat a spicy vodka square slice with extra-crispy pepperoni while also contemplating a painting of a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle. The pizza at this Bath Beach spot is pretty classic, with a bright sauce, and we’d ingest unhealthy amounts of it if we lived around Bensonhurst. They have a tiny back dining room and a full menu, in case you want to pair your pie with some rigatoni, garlic knots, or house-made rainbow cookies.

If the love child of penne alla vodka and New York-style pizza sounds like it could be your zodiac sign, you’ll love Krispy Pizza. This Bensonhurst slice shop specializes in Frankenstein-ish pies, from the eyebrow-raising Salad Pizza to the extremely delicious spicy vodka pepperoni square pie, which displays pure genius in its use of roni cups on top of sliced pepperoni. With combinations like these, it should come as no surprise that Krispy Pizza gained notoriety on TikTok, but the food here lives up to the hype.

One of New York’s oldest pizzerias, J&V has been around since 1950, and yet their approach has an innovative twist. You’ll find very good simple slices here—cheese, pepperoni, a great white slice, etc.—but there’s a lot of other stuff worth trying. Take, for example, their fresh tomato and garlic pizza, which has a super thick, almost focaccia-like crust, but is still a round pie. You can also get this crust variety with bacon and cheddar on top, if that’s more your style. Their signature dish is the Chicken Jojo, a chicken patty parm stuffed inside of garlic focaccia. It’s as good as it sounds.

Chase Sapphire Card Ad

Suggested Reading

a margherita slice with parm and a basil leaf from L'industrie in the West Village

The 21 Best Pizza Places In NYC

The top 21 pizzas in NYC, according to us.

a few pastas and other dishes from Roscioli in NYC

Where to eat Italian in NYC when you aren’t willing to settle.

The Best Pasta In NYC image

Few things are going to make you as happy as a bowl of perfectly prepared carbohydrates.

Infatuation Logo

Company

2024 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.

FIND PLACES ON OUR APP

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store